Beyond Resilience: Why Marketing Leaders Need Disruption Fluency Now
The language we use reveals how we think. When we talk about "weathering storms" or "surviving change," we're treating disruption as an occasional crisis, something that interrupts normal business. But what if disruption is normal business now? And what if, rather than treating like a crisis, we as marketing leaders can intentionally design our organizations to harness it as a competitive advantage?
Consider what today’s marketing leaders face simultaneously: AI transforming production and personalization at scale (and most everything else), fractured privacy regulations constantly rewriting targeting options, social platforms and trends rising and falling over months if not faster, generational shifts in media consumption, this rising power of creators, wildly unpredictable economic volatility, and politically-charged brand pressures from every direction. Any one of these would be considered disruptive. Together, they're simply the reality we face every day.
The question isn't whether your marketing organization will face disruption and how it survives it. It's whether you're building the organizational capability and leadership model to thrive within it. This is what I call Disruption-Fluent Marketing.
Disruption-Fluent Marketing is the organizational capability to anticipate, absorb, and capitalize on discontinuous change through adaptive leadership structures, transformational vision, and agile operational practices.
What Fluency Actually Means
Fluency implies more than competence. You don't just understand a language; you think in it naturally, spontaneously, even creatively. Likewise, disruption-fluent leaders and organizations don't merely respond to change—they anticipate it, absorb it, and capitalize on it.
This isn't about moving fast and breaking things. It's not reactive chaos or abandoning strategic thinking. Rather, it's about building organizational capabilities (and culture) that integrate discipline with flexibility, strategic vision with tactical responsiveness.
Drawing from Complexity Leadership Theory, transformational leadership research, and the Agile Marketing Manifesto, disruption-fluent marketing organizations operate differently across three dimensions: their leadership structures, their cultural commitments, and their operational practices.
Rethinking Leadership: Three Functions, Not One
Traditional leadership models largely assume predictability and top-down control. They work brilliantly for efficiency and scale but often struggle when environments become turbulent. Modern marketing, with its rapid technological change, fragmented landscapes, and unending performance and ROI expectations, demands something different.
Complexity Leadership Theory, developed by Mary Uhl-Bien and colleagues, views organizations as complex adaptive systems where three distinct leadership functions must coexist:
Adaptive Leadership is the emergent, creative problem-solving that occurs when diverse people collaborate on novel challenges. It's the cross-functional team that rapidly pivots a campaign based on unexpected social sentiment, the regional marketers who surface and champion local insights challenging corporate assumptions, the product marketing team that quickly pivots established messaging based on novel competitors moves. Adaptive leadership can’t, and shouldn’t, be controlled, only enabled. It emerges bottom-up from interactions in context of a healthy culture, not strictures defined by top-down authority.
Administrative Leadership represents what we tend to think of as traditional management functions: planning, coordinating, budgeting, measuring. Far from obsolete, administrative leadership remains essential for operational excellence and scale. Brand standards, financial governance, compliance processes, these require structure and control. The concept of Minimum Viable Bureaucracy (MVB), a play on the Minimum Viable Product (MVP) concept first popularized by Eric Reis (in The Lean Startup) and others about 20 years ago, is critical here, as in a disruption-fluent culture the focus must be on providing important process and structure, but only to the minimum extent necessary.
Enabling Leadership is the critical bridge between the other two. It creates "adaptive space" where innovation can flourish while managing the inevitable tension between bureaucratic requirements and creative freedom. It’s about harnessing “productive tension” to fuel strategic thinking, creativity, and innovation. It’s setting the culture, promoting psychological safety, securing budget and resources, creating “creative headspace” for ideas to thrive, and perhaps most importantly, it’s about a marketing leader’s responsibility to protect all that from interference or suppression from outside the team.
The magic lies in what researchers call "entanglement”: these functions must interact fluidly and dynamically. Too much administrative control stifles innovation. Too much adaptive chaos prevents scale and risks quality. Senior marketing leaders must become skilled at balancing and harnessing these tensions, not suppressing or resolving them permanently.
Transformational Leadership: The Inspirational Fuel
While Complexity Leadership Theory provides the structural framework for creating resilient organizations that can react effectively to disruption, transformational leadership supplies the inspirational energy that drives a proactive commitment to change. Research shows that effective transformational leadership increases openness to change while reducing resistance and cynicism, exactly what disruption-fluent organizations need.
Transformational leaders inspire through four dimensions: modeling desired behaviors (idealized influence), articulating compelling vision (inspirational motivation), challenging assumptions (intellectual stimulation), and developing people individually (individualized consideration).
When we think of “leaders” this is often what we think of, the Steve Jobs archetype. However being transformational, or inspirational, isn’t sufficient by itself. Transformational leadership can provide a critical spark, but without the other tenants of this framework (adaptive, administrative, enabling, and as you’ll see below, agile), a spark with no engine won’t make it very far.
Agile Principles: Operationalizing It All
Theory becomes reality through practice. Agile methodologies, drawn originally from software development but now used by 75% of marketing teams, provide the operational foundation to make it all work at scale.
The Agile Marketing Manifesto emphasizes five values particularly relevant to disruption fluency:
- Customer value over activity: Measure outcomes that matter, not outputs or simple activity
- Early and often over perfection: Reduce risk through rapid learning cycles that provide value to the business quickly and continuously
- Experiments and data over opinions: Demand empirical thinking rather than defaulting to the loudest voice in the room
- Collaboration over silos: Enable the interactions and diversity of thought and representation that generate true innovation
- Responding to change over following a plan: Plans and strategy certainly matter, but adapting course through applied learning matters more
Practices like sprints (time-boxed work cycles), daily stand-ups (rapid coordination and clear communication), retrospectives (systematic and open learning), and tools like Kanban boards (workflow transparency) help operationalize these values. They create rhythm, surface problems early, and enable continuous adaptation.
The Path Forward
Building disruption fluency in a marketing team isn't a one-time initiative, it's an ongoing commitment as both a leader and as an organization. Start by assessing where adaptive leadership already shows up in your organization (often in unsanctioned pockets). Develop enabling leadership thinking in yourself and your senior team. Rigorously audit process with an eye towards MVB. Pilot agile approaches and techniques with your teams, then apply and scale what works based on evidence.
The most dangerous thing you can do as a marketing leader in a world of perpetual disruption is stand still. The second most dangerous is to view disruption and change as a threat. It’s an opportunity to be seized by marketing leaders and organizations that proactively embrace disruption and shape their actions to leverage it.
Explore more
Learn more
